Greetings y'all :
Most folks will agree that motivation is key. We are all motivated by something to do something. We have extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. We strive to do our best and to be successful with the use of motivation. We may internalize or sense of competition and desire to do our best to be more creative and productive on our job. We may even find we receive verbal praise or maybe promotions and pay rises by thinking outside the box. We feel good when we are rewarded for creativity and it encourages us to further growth. Conversely we may find our thinking outside the box, building a better mousetrap as it were , being squelched and under appreciated. We then feel frustrated but realize we also have the flexibility to find an employer who appreciates and stimulates who we are.
Now suppose you went to work and had very little ability to do whole brain learning, to think creatively, or to put who you are into your career. You are expected to be a silent cog in the machinery. I understand some folks may find this scenario comforting, but many will tilt against these windmills.
Which situation is more idealistic? Which situation is more realistic ? Which situation is more stressful? Which situation is more stimulating?
Now I ask you what about being a quirky,exuberant , and creative child? Children are told to stop watching the magic talking moving picture box, stop playing video games, to get outside and play and explore. However they are being told to sit quietly in the classroom or risk losing recess. How do we reconcile this? What is the motivation for these children? Good grades ? Avoid punishment ? I posit those are forced extrinsic motivators.
I find , and this is simply my own humble opinion, that many children like to explore. The proverb goes give a man a fish he eats for a day, teach a man to fish he eats forever. Are we simply spooning information to students , expecting them to quietly digest it. Is it not better to let them discover the knowledge and therefore own it?
Creativity is something which can be culled or quelled. How do we tap into a child's intrinsic motivation? How do we genuinely allow a child to take ownership of life long active learning? I fear industrialized style of education is denying our future generations of the ability to lead and think creatively.
I'll step down from my soap box for the moment . Thanks for listening to my rant.
Meanwhile back at Mowgli. Yes part of rant was about how he may seem to be off task or off topic but if one investigates he's not being disrespectful and rude but is oft times taking the base knowledge being taught and expanding it with what ifs. He is a experiential eight year old who thinks outside the box and beyond the basic instruction. Admittedly he needs to learn how to better is present in thoughts in a more respectful manner, but again he is eight. Is he angry? Yeppers he's had experiences no child should have. Many children have it worse but I'm raising this one not the others. I was told yesterday " wait he's bright , he's eight and he's angry? Ok so what's the problem ? Many bright and angry eighteen year olds can't fully grasp or articulate their feelings " I have to admit I love working in BLS, tis my calling but my child belongs in the original placement of GT third grade not the BLS program. His self control in group settings has increased exponentially! Is it the actual school setting? No but he needs to be challenged academically. We, he and I , are reading Rudyard Kiplings unabridged version of 'Captains Courageous ' and he is able to digest it.How many eight year olds enjoy reading books on the elements? How many can bake bread from scratch ? Can explain how a steam engine works? Have a good understanding of the government? Many children out pace him but he is the bright bulb in my lamp.
Oops sorry for another rant folks.
Thanks for listening yet again. Remember all feedback , both positive and negative , help facilitate growth in all of us. A few folks say they my mindless meandering mumblings on here but feel they have little to add. I say balderdash ! Every sentient being gas valid thoughts and opinion. Plato showed us that life in the cave is restrictive.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
For some reason I can't edit the blog on my phone . First of all sorry for the typos . Secondly I think I missed the point of finding what motivates our progeny to learn and grow but also what the motivation is for their behaviours . Thanks
ReplyDeleteSounds like you both belong in a Montisori(sp?) program. I had a student that I worked with in one of them in my county and I loved visiting there. Being raised in, and working in, a traditional educational environment, I found their methodology a great alternative.
ReplyDeleteI would love to be able to afford a Montersorri program or homeschool my lad. He's well suited for either.
DeleteThanks
(Fem) In a progressive school, especially with such a focus on inclusion and differentiation, I would think Mowgli could fit beautifully in a gen ed classroom. I don't know how comfortable you are in talking to the teachers or administration (since you also work there), but one of the things I loved to do during a block of time that it typically quiet (reading/literacy), was provide choices (anywhere from 9 to 16) for the students to work on during that time. Their task was to pick 3 or 4 (of 9 or 16) and complete them over a time period of 2 or 3 weeks. They could work on any or all of them on any given day. They just had to finish them by the due date. The tasks might be: write a poem or rap about Columbus' voyage to the New World; make puppets and a short puppet show demonstrating a typical day in the life of an early settler in America; research create a three-fold brochure about a particular plant, including basic facts and fascinating trivia; consider what today's world would be like if early explorers of the Atlantic had reached Northern Canada long before ever reaching the West Indies and South America - how might life be different? Anyway, I called this chunk of assignments a Tic-Tac-Toe and placed assignments of different levels and learning styles to try to accommodate the needs of the students. My principal said he wasn't sure learning was going on if students weren't actively engaged (moving around, gathered around tables, on the floor) in the lessons.
ReplyDeleteIf the class sizes aren't huge, I wouldn't think it would be such a problem to place him in gen ed - I had thirty in my class and I had 6 "high minutes" sp. needs children in my class - all of who were on the low side of academic abilities, but 2 who had emotional issues as well. It takes some patience and dedication, but it can and should be done (inclusion, I mean).
That's my 2 cents.
You have some great and creative ideas. Wow - thank you. I would like to see him in gen ed his intelligence is amazing but there is some anger under the surface. I like the idea of having additional supports snd the staff at my school is amazing . I'm really troubled about him going into the BLS program , I still feel the episodes he had this week were avoidable . But here we sit with more ammo against him.
ReplyDelete